Finance Spyder
Follow the evidence, not the tip

Markets & Economy

Reading the economy without a forecast

Understanding the environment is useful; predicting it is not, and the distinction determines what is worth following.

A vibrant cityscape featuring modern skyscrapers reflecting the blue sky and clouds.
A vibrant cityscape featuring modern skyscrapers reflecting the blue sky and clouds. · Photo via Pexels
Financial information notice. Analysis and education — not personalised financial advice. Read the full disclaimer.

There is a difference between understanding the economic environment you live in and attempting to predict it, and only one of them is achievable.

What is worth understanding

For a household rather than a trader.

The direction of interest rates, since it affects mortgages and savings directly.

The inflation rate relative to your own wage growth, which determines whether you are getting better or worse off.

The labour market in your own sector, which affects income security.

Housing costs in your area.

And fiscal policy affecting taxes and public services.

These affect decisions you actually make, unlike the aggregate figures that dominate coverage.

The indicators worth following

A short list.

Central bank policy rates and guidance, which determine borrowing and saving costs.

Inflation, in the measure that reflects your own spending.

Wage growth relative to inflation.

Unemployment and vacancies in your sector.

And housing market conditions if you are buying or selling.

Everything else is context rather than input.

What not to follow

Which is most of it.

Daily market movements and their explanations.

Forecasts of any kind, given the record.

Individual data releases, which are revised and which are priced within seconds.

Commentary about what markets will do.

And anything framed as a warning of an imminent crash, which is produced continuously.

The distinction that matters

Between two activities.

Understanding: knowing what is happening and what it means for your circumstances, which supports better decisions about jobs, housing, borrowing and saving.

Predicting: attempting to determine what happens next in order to position a portfolio, which the evidence suggests is not achievable and which produces the behaviour gap.

Which means economic literacy is valuable and economic forecasting is not, and confusing them is where the time is wasted.

Positioning a life rather than a portfolio

The useful application.

Income security matters more than portfolio positioning for most households, which means employability, skills and sector matter.

Fixed costs determine resilience, which is within your control.

Debt levels determine sensitivity to rate changes.

An emergency fund determines whether a downturn is an inconvenience or a crisis.

And these are all adjustable in response to circumstances in a way that a diversified portfolio is not.

The questions worth asking

Periodically.

Is my income secure, and what would happen if it stopped?

Are my fixed costs manageable if rates rise or income falls?

Is my debt at a level I could service under stress?

Do I have a buffer?

Is my wage keeping pace with inflation, and if not, what would change that?

And are my skills current in a sector with demand?

None of these require a forecast, and all of them improve resilience regardless of what happens.

Where the environment does change a portfolio

For balance.

A change in your own capacity for loss, arising from reduced job security, should change the allocation.

A change in horizon should change it.

A change in circumstances that alters the objective should change it.

None of which is a forecast about the economy — all are facts about you.

Which is the correct basis for a change, and which is distinguishable from a view about the future.

Sources worth using

Practically.

Statistical offices' own publications, which include the confidence intervals and revisions that coverage omits.

Central bank publications and minutes, which explain reasoning.

Long-form analysis of what has happened, as distinct from prediction of what will.

And sector-specific sources for your own industry, which are more relevant to your income than aggregate figures.

The frequency

Which should be low.

Quarterly is sufficient for understanding the environment.

Daily consumption produces no additional understanding and produces reactions.

And the correlation between how much economic news someone consumes and how well their portfolio performs is, if anything, negative.

The conclusion

Which applies throughout.

Economic understanding helps with decisions about work, housing, borrowing and resilience.

It does not help with portfolio positioning, because everything known is already in prices.

Which means the useful response to economic uncertainty is a robust household and a diversified portfolio, rather than a view.

General information only, not investment advice. Investments can fall in value and past performance does not indicate future returns. Consult a regulated financial adviser.

economyindicatorscontexthousehold
Anton Brekke
Editor, Finance Spyder

Anton managed multi-asset portfolios for eleven years and has become steadily less interested in forecasts over that period.

More from Anton →

Also by Anton Brekke

Markets & Economy

The evidence, summarised

What the research actually supports, stated plainly, and what remains genuinely uncertain.

Anton Brekke··3 min read

Markets & Economy

Housing markets and what drives them

Supply, credit conditions and rates dominate, and the asset behaves differently from anything in a portfolio.

Anton Brekke··3 min read

Markets & Economy

Central banks and what they actually do

Their tools, mandates and constraints are specific, and understanding them explains most of what markets react to.

Anton Brekke··3 min read

Behaviour

Knowing when to do nothing

Action bias produces most of the damage in retail investing, and inaction is an active choice rather than an absence of one.

Clara Mensah··3 min read

Behaviour

Automating your investing

Every decision removed is a decision that cannot be made badly, and the evidence on discretion is not encouraging.

Clara Mensah··3 min read

Risk & Volatility

Preparing a portfolio for someone else

A portfolio that only one person understands is fragile, and the failure mode arrives at the worst possible time.

Clara Mensah··3 min read